In this episode of Auction Is Action with U in It!, Bobby D. Ehlert shares what Call to Auction is observing across the fundraising event landscape in 2026: a pattern that might feel alarming on the surface but tells a much more encouraging story when you look at the right numbers.
Attendance at some events is down. Paddle raise participation is up. Live auction revenue is up. Overall fundraising results are getting stronger. And national data backs it up.
What the Data Is Showing
According to the Giving USA 2026 report on 2025 charitable giving, total charitable giving reached $561.2 billion, up 5.7%. Individual giving came in at $394 billion, up 4.1%. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project found that dollars raised were up 5% in 2025 while the number of donors declined by 3%. And just 2.9% of donors accounted for 76.4% of total dollars raised.
The picture that emerges: more money with fewer donors. Generosity is growing, but giving is becoming more concentrated. Donors are narrowing the number of organizations they support, going deeper with the ones they trust, and prioritizing relationships and meaningful causes over breadth.
What donors are looking for comes down to three things: trust in the organization, evidence that their money is making a real difference, and a personal sense of connection to the mission.
What Bobby Is Seeing in the Room
Across 40-plus fall events in 2026, Call to Auction is observing several consistent patterns.
Paddle raises are getting stronger. More guests are participating, there is greater willingness to make meaningful gifts, and stronger emotional connection to the mission is driving the ask. Donors want to know exactly what their gift accomplishes, and when that answer is clear and compelling, they give.
Live auctions are performing better with fewer, higher-quality items. Guests are spending more on unique experiences: exclusive access to a celebrity, investor, or influencer; curated chef’s table dinners at someone’s home; international travel to destinations like Tuscany, France, Portugal, and Greece. Competitive bidding and greater enthusiasm are consistent themes. The organizations seeing the biggest financial wins are using consignment vendors for experiential travel packages.
Participation rates are rising. Call to Auction has seen average household participation rates grow from around 55% to 67% across events this fall. And yes, 100% participation is possible. Bobby has seen 110%, where guests give more than once.
Three Real Results from Fall 2026
Treasure House Gala: $277,000 in live auction revenue, up nearly $100,000 from the prior year. $357,000 in the paddle raise with 71% household participation. Total live fundraising: $634,000.
Community Health Alliance: $134,000 in combined live auction and paddle raise revenue, up approximately 128% from their 2025 event, which was run without a professional fundraising auctioneer.
54 Below, New York City: Budgeted $20,000 for the paddle raise. Raised $54,000, nearly triple the goal, after hiring a professional.
Five Things Nonprofits Should Focus On
1. Measure participation rate, average gift, and revenue per guest.
Stop measuring success by headcount. Track household participation rate, average gift size, and revenue per guest. These numbers reveal trends that total revenue alone cannot. A 200-person event consistently outperforming a 500-person event is not unusual right now. Know your numbers year over year.
2. Build deeper relationships throughout the year.
The obligatory tax letter a few weeks after the gala is not stewardship. Donors need to feel connected to the organization between events. Coffee meetings, facility tours, impact updates, personal calls from board members: these are the touches that convert a one-time gala attendee into a long-term supporter.
3. Demonstrate impact clearly and specifically.
Show donors what their generosity accomplished. When the executive director or board chair can stand at the podium and say: because of your generosity last year, we helped this many more people, served this many more families, expanded this program by this much, and tonight we have a chance to go even further, that statement is worth more than any auction item or revenue game on the floor.
4. Create more engaging, donor-centered experiences.
The donor is the hero of the event. Design the evening around making them feel that. When guests feel their time, attention, and dollars are genuinely making a difference, participation goes up, giving goes up, and the relationships that follow the event get stronger.
5. Grow your donor base and find the new givers in the room.
When 76% of dollars come from 2.9% of donors, the opportunity in the other 97% is enormous. Many guests at your event want to give but need an accessible entry point and a reason to trust you first. Create giving levels that welcome everyone. Treat first-time givers as the beginning of a relationship, because they are watching how you respond. The signup party model, where lower-level donors buy into a shared experience, is one effective way to bring new people into the development conversation.
What 2026 Is Teaching Us
A full ballroom does not guarantee a successful fundraising event. The organizations building the strongest results right now are focusing on connection, trust, and whether their guests believe deeply enough in the mission to take action. What would happen if instead of spending months trying to get 100 more people into the ballroom, you invested that same energy in inspiring the 200 already there to become more deeply invested in the mission?
The organizations positioned for success in 2027 are the ones building those relationships now: before the event, during the event, and long after the room goes dark.
FULL TRANSCRIPT
Bobby D.:
Bobby D. here, your host of the Auction Is Action with You in It podcast. Billion-dollar fundraiser, 20-plus years of experience, world champion auctioneer, founder and CEO of Call to Auction. And I am excited to be talking about today because we are going to be talking about something interesting that is happening at fundraising events across the country.
At Call to Auction, we are seeing attendance at some events is down. We are seeing paddle raise participation is up. Live auction revenue is up. And overall fundraising results are getting stronger and stronger. Fewer people in the room does not necessarily mean less money raised.
Are we seeing a decline in fundraising events, or are we witnessing a shift in how donors are giving?
The Giving USA 2026 report on 2025 giving talks about total charitable giving at $561.2 billion, up 5.7%. Individual giving is $394 billion of that, up 4.1%. Now, the Fundraising Effectiveness Project in 2025 shows dollars raised are up 5%, but the number of donors is down 3%. What we are seeing is that 2.9% of donors accounted for 76.4% of the dollars raised in the Fundraising Effectiveness Project. Major donors are giving more money and the donor number is shrinking slightly.
What we think is happening: more money with fewer donors. Generosity is not disappearing, but giving is becoming more concentrated. Donors are narrowing the number of organizations they support. Instead of giving to ten organizations, they might be focusing on three or four. They are going deeper with the organizations they trust. They want to see impact. They want to see results. They want to be part of the organization. They are prioritizing relationships and meaningful causes.
Here are three things donors are looking for. Trust: do I believe in this organization? Impact: is my money truly making a difference? And connection: do I feel personally invested in the mission? Donors are giving more intentionally. This is my interpretation of donor behavior based on the 40-plus events we conducted this past fall season, not a trend directly measured by Giving USA. But this is what we are seeing.
Paddle raises are getting stronger. We love the paddle raise. We love the call to action. We love the big ask. And what we are seeing is more guests participating, greater willingness to make meaningful gifts, stronger emotional connection to the mission, and guests who want to know exactly what their gift accomplishes. We need to measure this, showcase this, and make it easy for donors to give within the paddle raise.
What makes the difference is powerful storytelling. A great video or in-person testimonial that talks about the impact on a life or a cause. More authentic, more dynamic storytelling. Clear impact statements showing lives touched, dollars raised, and what even one individual’s experience looks like. And a compelling invitation to give. Your donors will not give unless they are asked. Set the expectations that this is a fundraising event. Do not be afraid of the f-word: fundraising. Tell people there will be a paddle raise, a call to action, a community giving moment. Put those expectations out there.
To make sure this is as successful as possible, you need a fundraising professional on stage. I am tooting our horn and the horn of all fundraising auctioneers. There are only a few moments at your event that are so vital. The golden goosebump moment, when your guests understand what they are raising money for and are on the edge of their seats with their paddle in hand, ready to go: those moments are key. If you have someone inexperienced making that ask and they miss the mark or create the record scratch, you are going to lose tens of thousands of dollars. The investment in a fundraising event professional returns enormous ROI.
We are also seeing live auctions performing better. Guests are willing to spend more on unique experiences: exclusive access to a celebrity, a business owner, an investor, an influencer. Curated chef’s table dinners at someone’s home by celebrity chefs are selling very well right now. Nobody has to go anywhere and everybody loves a great experience. We are also seeing demand for more exotic travel destinations. Gone are the days when Napa and Sonoma dominated every auction. Now it is Tuscany, France, Portugal, Greece. The organizations seeing the biggest financial wins are using consignment vendors for experience travel.
Fewer items, higher quality items. Competitive bidding and greater enthusiasm. And a fundraising event professional in that audience stirring up the emotion, the engagement, the energy, and the enthusiasm. That is what professionals specialize in. That is what they get paid to do.
Here are a few examples from recent events. A few weeks ago I hosted the Treasure House Gala. We had a $277,000 live auction, up almost $100,000 from the year prior, all built around unique experiences. Then $357,000 in the paddle raise with about 71% household participation rate. Total live fundraising: $634,000. The Community Health Alliance raised $134,000 in combined live auction and paddle raise, up approximately 128% from their 2025 event, which was run without a professional fundraising auctioneer. And 54 Below in New York City had budgeted $20,000 for their paddle raise. We raised $54,000, nearly triple what they thought was possible. They simply did not know what they did not know. They hired a professional and got to see these results.
It is not about how many items you sell. It is about creating experiences that people want to invest in and tying that investment to your mission and your impact.
So what does this mean for nonprofits? Here are five things to focus on.
One: stop obsessing over attendance. Look at participation rates, average gifts, and revenue per guest. Measure these year over year. Are you growing or shrinking? We are seeing more fundraising happen at 200-person events than at 400 or 500-person events.
Two: build deeper relationships throughout the year. Stay connected with your donors throughout the year, not just at the gala and not just through the obligatory tax letter a couple of weeks after. Cultivate and steward those relationships. Help your donors become more involved with your organization.
Three: demonstrate the impact. Show donors what their generosity actually accomplishes. There is nothing better than an executive director or board president who can stand at the podium and say: because of your generosity last year, we were able to grow by this much, help this many more people, save this much more land. And tonight we have an opportunity to do this even bigger and better.
Four: create better experiences. Make your event more engaging, more emotional, and more donor-centered. The donor should be the hero of the night. When they feel their investment of time, attention, and dollars is truly making a difference, you will see more participation and more generous giving.
Five: grow participation and find new donors. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project shows that 76% of dollars raised come from just 2.9% of donors. What about the other 97% who want to help? Create different levels of giving so everyone can be involved. Many new guests at events want to make a test donation and see how they are treated afterward. They want to know their gift is recognized and that it is making an impact. The paddle raise is one way to engage the full audience. A signup party, where lower-level donors buy into a shared experience, is another. Those become development opportunities where your team can have real conversations and begin building deeper relationships.
What if instead of spending months trying to get 100 more people into the ballroom, you focused on inspiring the 200 people already there to become more deeply invested in your mission? Think about how much time you would save. Think about the results you would see. It is about dollars per donor, not dollars per guest.
Here is what 2026 is teaching us. A full ballroom does not guarantee a successful fundraising event. Generosity is alive and well and fundraising continues to grow. People want to make a difference. With all the uncertainty in the world, they know the organizations they trust can be part of their own story and their own legacy. But donors have choices, and trust matters more than ever. The organizations building the strongest relationships right now will be positioned for success in 2027.
Connection matters. Trust matters. Whether your guests believe deeply enough in your mission to take action matters. Focus on how many people are truly connected to your mission. Because fundraising is about generosity, participation, engagement, and the impact your donors are having.
Thank you all for investing time in your event by watching or listening to this content. It shows you have a desire and a dedication to make events better. Better events mean more fundraising. More fundraising means more relationships. More relationships mean more mission impact beyond the event. That is what it is all about.
Thank you for your time, your attention, and for being part of this better event movement. Thank you to our sponsor, calltoauction.com. And do not forget there is a free download at galatoolbox.com: the event blueprint, a year-round guide to help design your next fundraising event.
My name is Bobby D. And remember: auction is action with you in it.
Ready to Raise More?
At Call to Auction, we specialize in turning galas and fundraising events into mission-driven, revenue-generating experiences. From paddle raises to live auctions, our team knows how to excite donors, engage audiences, and inspire generosity in the moment.